...
- Walter Kozlowski (Telstra)
- Beth Cohen (Verizon)
- Pankaj Goyal (AT&T)
- Tom Van Pelt (GSMA)
- Tomas Fredberg (Ericsson)
- Ahmed El Sawaf (stc)
- Mehmet Toy (Verizon)
- Sukhdev Kapur (Juniper)
- Karine Sevilla (Orange)
- Trevor Cooper (Intel)
- Toshiyasu Wakayama (KDDI)
- Suresh Krishnan
Agenda:
- Linux Foundation Anti-Trust Policy Not
- GSMA Anti-Trust Policy Notice
- Recording Policies:
- Agenda bashing:
- Next meeting - 6 January 2021 at 8:00pm UTC
- Anuket TSC Updates, first technical meeting of the Anuket TSC is scheduled for 5 January (Tuesday) at 14:00 UTC, see Meld Zone
- Agenda
- Next vF2F conference in February 2021: topics are required: Feb vF2F Feb 1-4: 2021 February LFN Developer & Testing Forum. Proposals due 15 January 2021. Put in the topic proposals here: 2021 February Developer Topic Proposals. Topics already done (as placeholders). , need descriptions:
- Hybrid, multi-cloud model: DC to Edge (Pankaj, Walter)
- Acceleration Abstraction (Petar, Tomas, Per)
- Beyond IaaS/CaaS for Cloud Infrastructure in RM (Petar, Pankaj, Walter)
- Telemetry, monitoring, observability (Sukhdev, Petar, Zlatko)
- Edge (Beth, Ahmed)
- All→ please add other topics if you want to present
Next release (Elbrus) M3 - 15 January 2021: Update on Elbrus Issues and PRs progress/actions and PRIORITIZATION
Review of the Elbrus MVP contents (needed by 20 December 2020):
Network/Hardware Management
Hardware Infrastructure Management: function and APIs
Tomas, Walter High
Elbrus MVP
Agreed
Issue 2050
Requirements for NBI from HIM: work in progress
Contents will be available during the week of 14th December; Tomas to raise relevant PRs
Primary & secondary networking
Tomas, Suresh, Gergely Medium
Elbrus MVP
Probably RA-2 topic, discuss with Tom K. Gergely, Georg Kunz, whether RM can help (prob general guidance and requirements)
Issue 2085: work in progress
Contents will be available during the week of 14th December; Tomas to raise relevant PRs
Operations
Security (workloads and infrastructure) - alignment with ONAP
Karine, Amy, Pankaj High
MVPClosed for Elbrus
Done from Elbrus MVP perspective
Karine reviewing FS.31 and FS.40 from GSMA FASG from the possible alignment perspective for post Elbrus
Operations and Life-cycle Management
High
Elbrus MVP
Action: Issue 2086; identify gaps in Chapter 9 - open fort comments
Proposed new structure of Chapter 9
9.1 Introduction (Walter, PR#2114 for review, further updates)
9.2 Configuration and Lifecycle Management (includes closed loop automation, Change Control)
9.3 Assurance
9.3.3 Assurance Overview (as is now)and reviews
Activities/actions:
(Sukhdev)9.3.2 Observability
Telemetry (Sukhdev)Sukhdev to raise relevant PRs with the contents based on reviewed google docs
9.3.3
9.4 Capacity Management (as is now)
9.5 Automation Work in Progress. All → use RM Automation Content for adding contents, remarks, next meeting on Automation scheduled for Monday 14 Dec at 12pm UTC, please contact Pankaj Goyal or Walter Kozlowski if you want to join.
9.5.1 Infrastructure LCM Automation ( including Platform Software and CI/CD) (Saad) - End-2-End understanding of what type of automation ought to be done on what layers and includes
- hardware configuration CI/CD
- networking automation
- software development CI/CD
- software deployment CI/CD (operator environment)
- Identify "Closed Loop Automation" as a Gap in Ch10
9.5.2
Application LCM AutomationWorkload onboarding automation (including CI/CD) (Saad) includes- workload onboarding automation - the scope for RM is to describe support only but leave the details to RA/RI;
- RM will state the requirements including for CI/CD for ensuring software security scans, image integrity checks, OS version checks, etc. prior to deployment -
- the tenant processes for application LCM (such as updates) are out of scope
9.5.3 Tenant creation automation
- requirements for enterprise processes prior to tenant creation on the platform
- networking automation
Security Automation => Chapter 7, Security; but compare with Observability/Telemetry
Networking Automation => Section 4.3 Networking; but cloud level automation networking aspects may be in Chapter 9Telemetry Sukhdev to raise relevant PRs with the contents based on reviewed google docs
9.5 Automation
9.5.1 Infrastructure LCM Automation
9.5.1.1 Hardware Configuration CI/CD Tomas to raise PR for others' input
9.5.1.2 Networking Automation Tomas to raise PR for others' input
9.5.1.3 Software Development CI/CD Saad to raise PR for others' input
9.5.2 Software Onboarding Automation and CI/CD Requirements
9.5.2.1 Software Onboarding Automation (done and merged into master)
9.5.2.2 Software CI/CD Requirements (done and merged into master)
9.5.3 Tenant Creation Automation
9.5.3.1 Pre-tenant Creation Requirements Beth, Pankaj, Walter to work on contents for PR#2129
9.5.3.2 Tenant Networking Automation Beth, Pankaj, Walter to work on contents
All: review PR #2123Automation (closed loop automation) Medium
Closed for Elbrus
Should be in part in LCM (Chapter 9) - Issue 2087
Proposed to include into Chapter 9 (see above)
All → please add comments thereGap 10.3.6 raised in Chapter 10
Observability/telemetry
Sukhdev, Zlatko, Petar Medium
MVP
Issue 2052 contains a link to a google document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BjRTIPVOs7vqZvvmd65CWX0vJU3YCGcq5McVyyxdXoY/edit?usp=sharing
open for commentsSee action om Sukhdev for 93.2 and 9.3.3
Acceleration Hardware acceleration abstraction
Petar, Tomas, Per, Walter High
MVP
Issue 2051;
PR# 2115 to create a structure
Initial text work in progress, plan to share within the week of 14th of Dec 2020
Structure created in PR# 2115 and merged into master
Petar, Tomas and Per to start loading the contents into the structure via PRs
Compute node acceleration (incl smartNICs, GPU, etc) TBA Programmable fabric TBA Network acceleration TBA
Action: All → review and comments from the TeamStorage Karine, Petar Medium
Closed for Elbrus
Needed a structure
Further details needed (all classes of storage)
Issue 2056: Need contributors and expertise https://etherpad.opendev.org/p/ecg-vptg-october-2020 it has a link to the June PTG notes
Action: Beth → provide a structure (PTG etherpad can be used); work in progress
Special use cases
Load balancing
Per, Sukhdev Medium Issue 2095: Per to provide concept description for comments
Per to inform about the status
Mutual discovery (workloads/infrastructure)
Sukhdev, Tomas Medium Issue 2088; Sukhdev to add the concept description for comments
Sukhdev to inform about the status
Service function chaining
Suresh, Sukhdev Medium
MVP
Issue 2089; text in Issue
for reviewAction: All → review PR#2118Suresh to create PR with the reviewed contents
Model for Enterprise Cloud
and Edge
Walter, Pankaj, Ahmed Medium
MVP
Issue 2049: Multi/hybrid cloud from Data Centre to Edge;
PR#2118
2067,approved and merged
Alignment with ONAP Investigate topics other than security Petar Low
Ongoing
Petar to present to RM meeting Alignment with GSMA OPG Investigate alignment points Walter Low
Ongoing
Depends on outcomes of joint OITF and OPG meetings Alignment with ORAN? Influence ORAN regarding telco cloud Ongoing Tomas raised this question as he participates in WG 6. Karine to find out how we could discuss possible dependencies, alignments, cloud principles.... Alignment with ODIM Martin Ongoing Bring to this meeting the actions, comments from previous sessions and vF2F Granularity of RM profiles Issue 2068
Ricardo as the new RA-2 leader has joined RM meetings
REview of RM Chapter 2 use cases All Issues 2067 Actions:
- Karine → inform the RM Team about O-RAN (WG 6) collaboration ver 2 of the design document (Cloud Platform) will be finalised by the end of November (reference conformance for K8s). The document will be available for CNTT by the end of January 2021.
- All→ please add vF2F topics if you want to present other topicsAll → use RM Automation Content for adding contents, remarks; next meeting on Automation scheduled for Monday 14 Dec at 12pm UTC, please contact Pankaj Goyal or Walter Kozlowski if you want to join.
Walter → write up a PR defining the Gap; Done PR#2123
- All → please add comments for Issue 2052 which contains a link to a google document: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1BjRTIPVOs7vqZvvmd65CWX0vJU3YCGcq5McVyyxdXoY/edit?usp=sharing
- Beth → provide a structure for Storage (PTG etherpad can be used)
- All → review Issue 2089 'Service Function Chaining', text in IssueAll → review PR#2118 on Multi-cloud, Hybrid model
Minutes:
- GSMA non-members who want to participate in OITF please contact Tom Van Pelt , tpelt@gsma.com. Those who are interested in GSMA PRD FS.31 - it is available at https://www.gsma.com/security/resources/fs-31-gsma-baseline-security-controls/
- Akraino meetings on Dec 17th: https://wiki.akraino.org/display/AK/TSC+2020-12-17++%28Thurs%29+7+am+Pacific (CNTT Edge presented by Beth and Ahmed)
- Cloud Native Network Functions (CNF) Working Group: https://github.com/cncf/cnf-conformance/pull/450
- Next vF2F conference in February 2021: topics are required: Feb vF2F Feb 1-4: 2021 February LFN Developer & Testing Forum. Proposals due 15 January 2021. Put in the topic proposals here: 2021 February Developer Topic Proposals. Topics already done (as placeholders). , need descriptions:
...