Date
Attendees
LF Staff: Heather Kirksey Jim Baker
Committee Members: Ryan Hallahan Rabi Abdel Trevor Lovett Trevor Cooper Kanagaraj Manickam Marc Price Bill Mulligan Olivier Smith Yan Yang (I was not able to capture full attendance as I was sharing material, please feel free to update as needed)
Proxies:
Guests:
Minutes
Announced Results of CVC and CNOVP Election Results
- CVC Chair - Lincoln Lavoie
- CVC Co-Chair - Yan Yang
- CNOVP Subcommitte Lead - Trevor Lovett
- CNOVP Subcommitt Co-Lead - Rabi Abdel
Continued Review of WS02 Findings
- Material updated based on F2F observations (material)
- Discussion Regarding Key Decisions from April F2F (NOTE: items in italics are quotes from the material)
- "CNTT’s RA-2 will be the location and hub for CNF Requirements"
- RA-2 can still refer to requirements and specifications outside of RA-2 (ex: CNCF Tug work), but the thought is it would be the hub
- Desire for CNF requirements to be hosted in a LFN project (if even indirectly)
- Some concerns raised that CNTT focus has been solely on infrastructure vs. true CNF requirements (ex: Cloud Nativeness)
- This means RA-2 can not point back to the Ref Model for CNF requirements.
- Action Item: Trevor Lovett & Rabi Abdel Need to confirm the scope and types of requirements that RA-2 will include and if lack of traceability to RM is a concern to be solved
- "NFVi Performance Testing will move out of the badging program, and move to a benchmarking initiative"
- Conformance with performance requirements may be needed in the future
- Creating the requirements at this time may not be achievable
- Focus would be on establishing a benchmarking initiative to standardize how benchmarking of the NFVI would be performed (example: what would be measured, what tools used, approved labs, etc.)
- OVP can play a valuable role in specifying how this benchmarking program would work even if we don't start with badging
- Benchmarking may evolve to explicit conformance requirements in the future
- Need a team focused on defining how this would work, tools to be used, and what is needed from the various project
- Proposal is to create a workstream to focus on this, but need volunteers
- "Performance testing of CNFs should be out of scope for OVP"
- Felt this may not be out of long term scope of OVP, but is out of scope for MVP.
- Statement will be revised to be specific to the MVP.
- Only made it through 3 bullets.
- "CNTT’s RA-2 will be the location and hub for CNF Requirements"
Action items
- Trevor Lovett & Rabi Abdel confirm the scope and types of requirements that RA-2 will include and if lack of traceability to RM is a concern to be solved
- All - Volunteer for Performance Benchmarking workstream