No Meeting on 2020-04-13

Attendees:

Name (Organisation)
Pankaj Goyal (AT&T)
Walter Kozlowski (Telstra)
Kelvin Edmison (Nokia)
Samuel Hellec (Orange)
Ahmed El Sawaf( STC)
Karine Sevilla (Orange)
Sukhdev Kapur (Juniper)
Abdulrahman Almuqbil (STC)
abdullah alharkan (STC)
Kodi Atuchukwu (Vodafone)
Johanna Heinonen (Nokia)
Toshiyasu Wakayama (KDDI)

Agenda and Minutes

Agenda Bashing
Antitrust Policy: https://r.lfnetworking.org/Antitrust%20Slide.pdf
Ahmed El Sawaf DPDK performance data and guidelines
- Ahmed and Abdulrahman presented their results (see presentation):
  - VNF architecture dependency
- Intel: https://fast.dpdk.org/doc/perf/DPDK_18_02_Intel_NIC_performance_report.pdf
- DPDK Performance PPT: CNTT_Performance_DPDK.pptx
OSTK Release Selection
- Need Moderator and Scribe for Wed April 22nd "OSTK Release Selection" session
  - Karine Sevilla : Moderator and Scribe
- OSTK Release Selection Etherpad
Status Overview
RA-1 Chapters 1 - 4 Status Report Ian Gardner
- Open Issues, Status and Action Items
RA-1 Chapters 5 - 7 Status Report Karine Sevilla
- Open Issues, Status and Action Items
RA-1 Chapters 8 Status Report Sukhdev Kapur
- Open Issues, Status and Action Items
AOB

Action Items

	Description	Due Date	Assignee	Status	Task In
1	Topology content		Ian Gardner	Issue #638> Changes to RA-1 Ch03 and Ch04	PR #1488
2	PR's Requiring Review		as per PR	PR # 1387	PR #1387
3	Flow Table			Raise issue for defining flows as per Ian Gardner comments in PR #1391: Issue #1454 created a network flow diagram or table covering how traffic is managed depending on network type: (we need a network guru to add the correct flows if I get any of this wrong) Tenant. Traffic uses gre/vxlan and flows from compute to compute and compute to controller Provider VLAN. Traffic flows directly to/from the compute node hosting the VM via OVS Provider VLAN DPDK. Traffic flows directly to/from the compute node hosting the VM via OVS-DPDK Provider VLAN SRIOV. ... Neutron NAT. Traffic flows from the compute node to the controller and is NAT'd CVR / DVR???
4	PR's Requiring fixes	Completed	Petar Torre	PR # 1389 Ahmed El Sawaf to provide a reference to RedHat et al performance sources/sizing guidelines and these can be included in the write-up.	PR #1389
5	OpenStack Mandatory Features		Manik Sidana	Issue #1156 – no PR Need inputs on mandatory features on the OSTK APIs. Pankaj to change Issue writeup to "alignment of requirements and features"
6	Security: Image Security		Yeeling Lam	Issue #1395 – no PR
7	Security: Hardening		Yeeling Lam	To open Issue and PR
8	Security: Confidentiality & Integrity	Completed	Karine Sevilla	Issue #1217 – no PR;	PR #1470
9	Barbican write-up in RA-1 Ch03/Ch04	Completed	Karine Sevilla	To raise Issue and Content Already exists in RA-1 Ch05	Issue #1453 PR #1462
10	Review SDN in RA-1 Ch 3.2.5	Completed	Ahmed El Sawaf Sukhdev Kapur	PR #1391 add a subsection on SDN and reference to Ch 3.2.5 Issue and PR for RA-1 Ch 3.2.5 upgrade	Issue #1443 PR #1444
11	SDN - Tungsten Fabric + any others(?)		Walter Kozlowski Ahmed El Sawaf	Testing when using monolithic plugin. Phase I: use Neutron APIs. For Phase II, Q: how to handle custom APIs? Get upstream (OSTK)/another project to define common (useful) SDN API extensions. What should be the CNTT position? Wait for CNTT Network FG to define position.
12	Security: Workload		Pankaj Goyal	RM 7.11.4 Workload Security Issue #1467 created	PR #1469
13	Security: LCM	potentially already covered?	Karine Sevilla	RM 7.11.6 Security LCM Appears to be covered in various chapters including other Security write-up and RA-1 7.2 NFVI and VIM Configuration Management and 7.3 NFVI and VIM Maintenance
14	Security: Monitoring & Logging	potentially already covered?	Karine Sevilla	RM 7.11.7 Monitoring and Security Audit Can we point to RA-1 7.4 Logging, Monitoring and Analytics