Attendees:

Please add your name in here:

Special Notes:



  • Weekly RM meetings are intended to
    • Plan RM and Network related work
    • Identify owners for new Issues/PRs
    • Track open Issues/PRs
    • Address technical issues that cannot be resolved online (i.e. resolve stalls)

Agenda:

  • Linux Foundation Anti-Trust Policy Not
  • GSMA Anti-Trust Policy Notice
  • Recording Policies:

  • Meeting Recording:

  • Agenda bashing
    • OITF Update: The NG subgroup for managing the RM as a GSMA PRD has been set up now. The group’s page would be available on the GSMA infocentre at this link: https://infocentre2.gsma.com/gp/wg/IR/OIT/Pages/Default.aspx and that’s where it should be joined. There is a “join group” button when you’re not a member yet. OITF tasks and next steps: CNTT RM management process in GSMA_v6.pptx. Kick-off meeting on 3 September 2020
    • LFN Webinar by Walter and Tomas "Evolution of the Cloud Infrastructure Reference Model and its applications", Thursday 20 August at   3pm UTC:
    • Proposal to deprecate "Approach" document as obsolete now, DONE: issue #1859 closed, PR #1886 merged 
    • Proposal to remove BOGOMETERS from all chapter of RM: AGREED, Walter to remove
    • Date for clean-up and handover  to GSMA: target 14 Sep with handover before end of September
    • Status of Security sections cleanup
    • Storage status
    • Status of LCM sections review/cleanup 
      • Walter Kozlowski review from the completeness perspective and recommends accepting the current scope of Ch 9 as sufficient for this Release.  Specific comments for the contents improvement can be still accepted through the normal Issue/PR process. If accepted this will close Issues: #365 and 586 CLOSED
      • Review Issue 586 Define a generic installer; do we want this in RM? General installer moved to RI-1, RI-2, so we do not need it RM, Issue to be closed. CLOSED
      • What is the role of Table 9-3? Updated in PR# 1891
      • Need to add specific requirements for Assurance in a table format, Sec 9.3 - need to create a separate issue and PRs, most likely post Baraque/handover
    • Multi-cloud gap into RM: PR #1857/1858
    • Next steps reg Gaps


Chapter.Section

Content

Status/Issues

Owner

Comments

Chapter 0https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/tree/master/doc/commonMerged/Closed

Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs

Chapter 1

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter01.md

Merged/Closed


Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs

Chapter 2

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter02.md

Merged/Closed


Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs

Chapter 3

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter03.mdMerged/Closed


Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs



Chapter 4.1, 4.2

Address issues


GSMA feedback

Issues:  958,  1765  

Ahmed


Issue #958 to reviewed by Walter Kozlowski and Petar Torre

Karine Sevilla to raise an issue to correct the ETSI reference and add a paragraph explaining how table 4-11 will be used in CNTT documentation

→ issue#1879 created → done in PR#1888 for REVIEW

Chapter 4.3

Network, new content (done)

Issue #587

Tomas

Issue #587 to be addressed by Tomas


Chapter 5.1, 5.2 (software)

Address issues


Merged/Closed





Chapter 5.3, 5.4 (Hardware)

Address issues


Merged/Closed


Karine


Chapter 6

Address issues


Merged/Closed

Pankaj


Chapter 7

Security

Rewrite, address issues

GSMA feedback

Issues: 366, 1754, 1755,

1881

Karine

Karine Sevilla  to create a list of sections needed assistance and request help from the group

Issue 1507 → review comments, this issue could be closed CLOSED

Clean up issue#1881 -> PR #1882

But the chapter still needs review and clean up for:

  •  section Root of trust: right place?
  • 7.6 content somehow redundant with 7.4.1 and a lot of details, e.g. on RTM, is it necessary here
  • 7.4.1.2:  list presentation could be enhanced

Walter to contribute to resolve these issues


Chapter 8

Conformance, Verification, and Certification

https://github.com/cntt-n/CNTT/blob/master/doc/ref_model/chapters/chapter08.md

Merged/Closed


Merged into master

Future updates via separate PRs

Chapter 9

LCM

Address issues


GSMA feedback/addressed

Issues, 365 (more contents needed), 586

Walter

Pankaj

Review Issue 586 Define a generic installer in RM meeting

ALL: Please review LCM Chapter 9 regarding  completeness so we can close issues #365 and 586 (as this section has been updated in the meantime)

Chapter 10.3.1

Discovery

New content

Issue: 1688

Sukhdev

Need to address comments and re-review (in GitHub)

Chapter 10.3.2

Load balancing

New content

Issue: 1689

Per

Need to address comments and review, PR# 1846 in review (in GitHub)


Chapter 10.3.3

Service Function Chain

New content

Merged/Closed



Chapter 10.3.4

Packet acceleration

New content

Merged/Closed



Chapter 10.3

New gap

New content

Issue: 255

Pankaj

Please remove the relevant gap from RA-1

Issue #255 – no content added related to the issue in RA-1 Ch08.

Appendix A

Address issues


GSMA feedback

Issues:1306, 1459

Walter


Overall editing

Address issues


GSMA feedback

Issues #1625 (number consistency)

Walter


Overall topics for Baraque (per Rabi’s plan)





Networking Modelling

Review RM and add/update content


Tomas


Networking & Storage Characterization

Review RM and add/update content

Issues: 1851

Karine

Petar

Chapter 2, storage profile defined review needed.

Section 3.2.3 Storage needs review WIP, issue #1851 → PR 1852

PR #1852 merged, Issue # 1851 closed

Full Containerization support

Review RM and add/update content

Issue #1359

Walter


HW Acceleration support

Review RM and add/update content

Issue: 155

Ahmed


Edge

Review RM and add/update content


Ahmed


Actions:

WK, Pankaj, Tomas → looke at the multi-cloud gap description in sec 10.3


Minutes:

  • No labels